Return of retail politics

by | Aug 22, 2022 | Editor's Blog | 2 comments

Last week, we heard a lot about Cheri Beasley’s “go everywhere” strategy. The U.S. Senate candidate is traveling to counties across the state, talking to voters, and trying to build momentum for her campaign in a state that has only elected on Democrat to the U.S. Senate once in the past 20 years. And it appears to be paying dividends. Polls have her tied or leading.

Yesterday, the Washington Post wrote a piece on Beto O’Rourke and his quest to become governor of Texas, a state that hasn’t elected a Democratic governor in more than 30 years. The Post writes, “Beto is holding more than 70 public events in 49 days trying to convince people in mostly small, rural and often incredibly red towns around the state that he should be their next governor.” O’Rourke is facing more hostile crowds than Beasley and is naturally more confrontational. The story says, “He lives to debate.”

Beasley and O’Rourke are making retail politics fashionable again. Instead of relying mostly on television, digital, and other paid advertising, the candidates are literally meeting candidates where they live. The tactic is long overdue in states like Texas and North Carolina. (To his credit, Jeff Jackson made a 100 county tour in his primary, but he was mainly talking to other Democrats.)

Neither Beasley nor O’Rourke will win most these counties that they are visiting. However, they might cut the margin and they might make voters, even those who oppose them, think slightly differently about the two Democrats. That’s the first step in ending the demonization that has led Democrats to hemorrhage rural votes. 

Democrats can’t continue to lose votes in rural and suburban areas if they hope to stay competitive in North Carolina. And they can’t govern very easily if they have no trust or respect in areas that might not make up a majority of voters but do make up a majority of municipalities. 

It’s tough competing against a conservative media complex that casts Democrats as opposed to everything sacred to rural voters. Paid advertising won’t work. People don’t believe what they see on TV or the internet unless it’s delivered by the hosts or platforms they trust. In-person visits might be the best way to penetrate the confirmation bias that partisans seek. As the article in Beto noted, his visits create a buzz and he often returns for second or third visits and the crowds grow each time. 

Democrats need to do something to improve their image with voters. In North Carolina since the first of the year, more than 43,000 Democrats have changed their registration to either Republican or unaffiliated. Only about 24,000 Republicans have changed their registration. That’s a problem for Democrats.

What Beto and Beasley are doing is a beginning and shouldn’t be judged just by the success of their campaigns. Democrats need to start connecting with voters who don’t agree with them on everything, or even disagree with them on most things. Taking the fight into territory with few votes may at least earn respect and that’s a first step to being heard.  

2 Comments

  1. George Entenman

    Paid advertising won’t work. People don’t believe
    what they see on TV or the internet unless it’s
    delivered by the hosts or platforms they trust.

    I find political ads off-putting and unbelievable, and I keep remembering way back when Bill Clinton sent thousands (probably more) of DVDs to people around the country. This was before the internet had gotten going for many Americans, so people looked at The Man from Hope. It took its time to tell a fascinating story.

    I also think about Dick Cheney. Damaging as he was to our country (telling us that there were weapons of mass destruction in Iraq but refusing to tell Hans Blix, head of the UN inspectors in Iraq, where they were!), Cheney did one thing I liked: he talked calmly and openly, rarely in campaign mode.

    I remember hearing Gary Hart at UNC talking to a roomful of students, listening to questions and giving long, thoughtful answers. People loved him. He came back to UNC a second time, this time in Carmichael, where he spoke entirely in one-liners to get cheers. I left deeply disappointed.

    Wouldn’t a TV ad that took a little time to go slower be more effective than a bunch of ads that just throw around accusations or lists of plans (Elizabeth Warren, whom I loved, drove me crazy with all her dang plans)?

    Maybe a little dramatization to get peoples’ attention? Maybe have a man attack her verbally and be convinced by her response?

    Just talk to people at a little more length?

    I don’t know, but all the focus groups and think tanks just have to come up with something more honest and real.

  2. RKent

    I know people who went unaffiliated for GOP primaries in NC to counteract the extreme right wing candidates and it seems to have paid off. I’d wait to see if a red wave is in the cards for NC…I certainly hope not.

Related Posts

GET UPDATES

Get the latest posts from PoliticsNC delivered right to your inbox!

You have Successfully Subscribed!