The GOP is engaged in the inevitable finger-pointing that occurs in the wake of defeat. I’m not going to lie: I’m enjoying watching it. The battle between two factions of Never-Trumpers is especially interesting.
On one side of the debate are the campaign professionals at the Bulwark, and on the other side are the ideological keyboard warriors at the Dispatch. Prior to Trump, both sides fought for Republican ideas and Republican campaigns. They both recoiled when Trump gained control of their party. Now, as MAGA loses influence, they are accusing each other of malfeasance in their opposition to Trumpism.
The Bulwarkers launched midway through Trump’s first term and sided with anyone who would oppose him. Bill Kristol co-founded the site and its leading voices include Sarah Longwell and Tim Miller. Longwell and Miller are veteran political operatives who bring a campaign perspective to the fight. Kristol founded the conservative magazine The Weekly Standard, which lost its funding because of its repudiation of Trump.
They saw Trump and MAGA as existential threats to the American experiment. As it became apparent that the GOP would not check Trump in any meaningful way, they became committed to defeating Republicans at the ballot box. They believed that if a conservative party was to be rebuilt, the GOP needed to be burned down first. They weren’t willing to compromise with MAGA.
By the time of the second Trump administration, the Bulwark had allied itself with Democrats and built a media operation that extended the center-left spectrum into the center-right. Their focus was more on electoral politics than ideology. They increasingly sounded more like moderate Democrats than disgruntled Republicans.
The Dispatchers were a different breed. Founders Jonah Goldberg and Stephen Hayes were refugees from National Review and The Weekly Standard, and both quit Fox News as it increasingly embraced MAGA. They saw themselves more as public intellectuals than political warriors. While they rejected Trump and MAGA, they focused more on advocating conservative policies than winning elections. They were generally supportive of Republicans when the party pushed policies they liked. They may have been disappointed when Republicans enabled Trump, but they did not advocate burning down the GOP house like the Bulwarkers.
In reality, both groups were centrist conservatives who found themselves politically homeless under the Trump-dominated GOP. The Bulwarkers embraced the role of the loyal opposition, believing that democracy was the way to defeat MAGA. The Dispatchers kept one foot in and one foot out of the GOP circle, opposing Trump’s most authoritarian measures but applauding conservative measures, especially in foreign policy.
In the end, the Bulwarkers became Democrats, shifting their ideology and building new alliances on the left. In doing so, they stayed in the fight. The Dispatchers became spectators, largely irrelevant to the main conversation, but waiting for a new and revised conservative movement. They aspire to provide the ideological backbone to the Republican Party in a post-MAGA world—or possibly a new conservative party.
Between those two factions—or maybe beside them—sits a host of Republicans who either embraced MAGA for political reasons or fully bought into its illiberal, autocratic view of the world. People like Thom Tillis may have been uncomfortable with MAGA’s authoritarianism, but they were unwilling to act forcefully against it until the movement destroyed them. Others like Tim Moore got in on the grift. They knew better, but the opportunities, both political and financial, were too great. And then some were so wedded to specific issues like abortion or gun rights that they stuck with Trump because the Democrats were somehow worse.
The rest of the Republican coalition under Trump was fine with everything. They cheered the ICE raids and internment camps. They agreed with the white nationalist rhetoric. They believed that Russia is a better ally than a bunch of socialist countries like Canada and Western Europe.
And that’s the rub. Those people, the ones animated by racial animosity and authoritarian strongmen, have always been central to Republican electoral success, long before Trump. And when Trump’s gone, they will still be there. They may get pushed to the back of the party like they were in the fifty years before Trump, but they will still be key to winning states with large, less-educated, predominantly white rural populations. Those are the people with whom the Dispatchers will need to make peace if they are going to again have ideological influence over the GOP.
I think Bill Kristol, Sarah Longwell, and the Bulwarkers have come to that conclusion, too, and basically said, “I’m out.” Instead, they’re joining a far more diverse and messier coalition that spans from the far left to a center left that may be redefining the center right.
Within that coalition, they are immediately relevant. In North Carolina, Paul Barringer, the Congressman-elect in the 13th District, fits the profile. He was a lifelong center-right Republican who could not live within the confines of Trumpism. People like him are the seeds of a broad centrist wing of the Democratic Party that can elect people in all parts of the country.
The Dispatchers, in contrast, are now rebuilding a movement made up of groups like John Hood’s Freedom Conservatism. They will largely sit out the political battles while trying to influence the political debate. For now, they are mostly in the wilderness, irrelevant to the dominant ideology of either party. They are taking the long view, waiting for an opportunity like the one that emerged in 1980 with the election of Ronald Reagan. For William F. Buckley, the opportunity took almost a quarter century.
MAGA is not completely done yet, but its impact is waning quickly. With Trump exiting the stage, the country will likely see another political realignment, or maybe the continuation of the current one. While the Democratic Party stays mostly intact with its diverse set of interests, the GOP will splinter, at least until it can unite fully against a strong Democratic majority.



I have some friends who left the GOP because they were appalled by Trump. They became unaffiliated independents, but chose to vote for Democrats here in NC
I have always been a registered Democrat and voted always for Democrats — sometimes with more enthusiasm than others. I’m quite liberal although in my personal life I’m fairly conservative.