Never Trumpers and the defeat of Donald Trump

by | Nov 24, 2020 | 2020 elections, Editor's Blog | 3 comments

Well, it’s over. With the certification of votes in Michigan, Donald Trump has lost the election and has ordered his administration to cooperate with the transition. He hasn’t conceded and right-wing networks like OAN are reporting that he still has a good chance of winning, but Trump will be playing to an even smaller base. The rest of the media will largely ignore whatever antics the president has in store for us. 

I have a sense of relief, though I know it will be temporary. Trump’s most ardent supporters are not going away. They will continue their grievance campaign, complaining about minorities and immigrants freeloading off the country  and liberals taking away their guns and threatening their religious freedom. Elected Republicans who refused to stand up to Trump will try to mimic his demagoguery to further their own careers and may even hone his tactics to undermine our democracy. Still, for now, I’m going to breathe easier and let down my guard for a few weeks. 

I am proud of the constant pressure Democrats and their progressive allies kept on Trump and the Republican Party that he remade in his image. They turned the Women’s March into an organizing tool that led to the highest turnout in a midterm election in decades. They built a political infrastructure that will be needed to compete in an evenly divided country. They did not give up on democracy, even if Trump and allies sought to undermine it. 

I am also inspired by the Never Trumpers and believe many people take for granted the difficulty of their decisions. They came from the campaign battlefield and the policy world. They are movement conservatives and public intellectuals. They are people at the top of their careers who have spent their lives promoting Republican politics and conservative ideals. They walked away because they believe our country and our democracy are more important than loyalty to a party led by a would-be despot. They made a sacrifice that cost them friends, colleagues, and jobs.  

As someone who has spent most of my life waging battles against their candidates and ideas, I have tremendous respect for the commitment they made to fighting what they believe is a budding authoritarianism. Some of the most astute critiques and assessments of the Trump administration and remade GOP have come from them. They see clearly the threat to our democracy through eyes not influenced by ideological differences. They are looking at their former allies and political comrades. 

Yesterday on twitter, David French, a former National Review writer, laid out the crimes of Donald Trump that Republicans have tried to suppress. He reminded us that the Mueller Report did not exonerate Donald Trump and his campaign but that Republicans covered up the misdeeds, distorting Mueller’s findings to suit their needs. He laid out the case for Trump’s impeachment, noting that the president asked a foreign government to interfere in our elections and the GOP refused to hold him accountable in any way.

David Frum, a former George W. Bush speechwriter, took to task those Republicans downplaying the president’s attempt to steal the election. He noted that not until the plan had failed spectacularly with convoluted fantastical conspiracy theories did most of the GOP finally concede and admit Biden’s victory. “Perhaps some excited person did over-react to something. That happens. But if you’re one of those belittling what the country just went through … The people who worried – they saved your country without you,” he tweeted. 

Progressives believe the Lincoln Project was a grift to make money for disheartened Republicans consultants. I saw it as people alarmed by Trump and the capitulation of the GOP to his authoritarian instincts using the skills they had to fight back. Did they make money? Sure. Good for them. A lot of consultants just got rich off a campaign cycle that saw almost $8 billion in expenditures. The Lincoln Project did as much to get under the skin of Donald Trump as anybody and forced the Trump campaign to address their attacks. 

I have no illusions that I still have strong policy disagreements with the Never Trumpers. I believe we need universal health care, an expanded social safety net, more affordable college, a higher minimum wage, stronger protection for the environment, a shift to green energy, criminal justice and police reform, and more liberal immigration policies. I don’t think many of the Never Trumpers would agree with much of that and that’s ok. Those are fights I’m glad to still have. 

My respect for the Never Trumpers comes from a belief that our country should be bigger than the political ideals of our political parties. Our system of government is one of checks and balances and that our way of choosing leaders is one of those checks. Democracy is not to be subverted to promote a political agenda. 

I’m not saying the Never Trumpers did more than anybody else to defeat Trump, but I am saying they had a more difficult choice. They set an example that we all should examine. Can we see clearly enough beyond our policy preferences to put country before party in an extremely polarized environment? I hope my answer is yes, but I also know that I have not been faced with that choice yet.  


  1. Mike

    “Did they make money? Sure. Good for them.”

    This is why this site badly needs a left perspective. While the Lincoln Project and other professional grifting operations skimmed millions of small-dollar donations for over-priced ads I’m thinking of the growing tent cities in Charlotte, the mile-long lines for food banks across this country, and a working class that is getting closer to mass-eviction in the middle of winter amid a deadly pandemic.

    If we stick to electoral politics, let’s talk about the dozens of state House and Senate campaigns this year that had 0 guidance and no money to work with. We have a real problem where “flashy” campaigns to run can’t-win campaigns in states like Kentucky and South Carolina suck up money that could have given local candidates a real chance. Even a $1000 investment in some of these down ballot races would have enabled a campaign that reached some voters the coordinated campaigns missed. With Chari Beasley a few hundred votes away from victory, that kind of grassroots support would have come in handy…

  2. j bengel

    The enemy of my enemy is not my friend, we just happen to have common cause at this point in history. I applaud Mitt Romney’s essentially singular opposition to Trump’s authoritarian mindset, but that doesn’t absolve him of his Randian attacks on the most vulnerable in our society (not that he ever sought absolution in the first place). I salute George W. Bush’s occasional volley in the direction of the Trump White House, but it will never rehabilitate his disastrous presidency or mitigate the damage he did. The Lincoln Project is run by people I disagree with on almost every point except one.

    But it is that one point that may, if we are very lucky or very good, open the door to a climate where those disagreements don’t have to be open warfare. We may yet be able to find our way back to a world where we can disagree without being disagreeable. Granted that’s a long shot as long as there are Mitch McConnell and Lindsay Graham (and Cruz, Cotton, Rubio, Cornyn…) but the possibility isn’t nonexistent, which it has appeared to be for the past 10 years or so.

    If that happens, then it could that Donald Trump did actually do something or the common good. Accidentally, of course, but no less good for that.

  3. Laura

    I couldn’t agree more. I’m pretty progressive myself, but the Never Trumpers gave me faith that the country hadn’t gone off the rails altogether. I was dismayed to see a lot of progressives dismissing them as the enemy.

Related Posts


Get the latest posts from PoliticsNC delivered right to your inbox!

You have Successfully Subscribed!