A firestorm over nothing

by | Oct 23, 2017 | Editor's Blog, Media, News | 4 comments

The latest debacle over Trump’s response to Gold Star families illustrates why people hate politics and have lost respect for both our leaders and our institutions. Nobody behaved well, not the president, not the congresswoman, not the press, and not the partisans pushing to score political points. The woman who lost her husband and is left to raise three children alone, including one on the way, gets ignored and becomes a footnote in the controversy.

The whole thing started when Trump and his administration ham-handedly handled the death of four soldiers in Niger. Instead of making a statement about their deaths or explaining why they were in the central African country, Trump was busy tweeting about football players and fake news. When the press asked him if he had reached out to families of the fallen, Trump felt compelled to say that he does more than his predecessors. (Of course he does. Nobody does more than Donald Trump on any matter. We all know that by now.) And doing what journalists do, the press fact checked him.

The media reported that Trump, in fact, had not reached out to families. The president then felt compelled to get in touch with Gold Star families ASAP. So he started calling. Bad idea. Trump lacks empathy so consoling families is a recipe for disaster. That said, he thought he was doing what he’s supposed to do. He just got the words tangled up. Unfortunately, Congresswoman Frederica Wilson was on the line when Trump mangled his condolences.

Wilson went straight to the press. They, in turn, went to Trump, who then lied and denied what he had said. From then on, the whole debacle turned into a day of he said/she said while most other news got lost in the firestorm. After a couple of days dominating the political news cycle, Chief of Staff and Gold Star father John Kelly gave a press conference describing what happens when a family receives notice that they’ve lost a loved one. He looked like the adult that the Trump administration needs and sounded like a caring man, deeply sympathetic to military families. Unfortunately, he also used the occasion to bash Rep. Wilson by mischaracterizing her words at a dedication ceremony she attended years ago.

By Friday, the firestorm had dominated the news for four days without any real point or useful information. To be clear, Trump started it to cover up for his silence on Niger by pointing fingers and lying. Rep. Wilson, though, had no reason to go public with the conversation between Trump and the war widow except to make him seem callous and uncaring, something most of us who oppose Trump already believe and something his supporters will never buy. The press, who’ve been relentlessly attacked by the president for presenting “fake news,” wanted to show that Trump was lying, again something we already know.

The debacle has leaked into this week with almost nothing gained. That Trump is a self-absorbed liar who lacks empathy is not news. That he botched a condolence call might have deserved a mention, but not a week of coverage. Kelly is far more sympathetic than the other political players or press, but even he couldn’t help trying score political points. He can’t be blamed for trying to cover for his boss but he can be criticized for not apologizing to Wilson for his mischaracterization.

While we were watching this four day story, we never found out why we’re in Niger or what happened to the four soldiers who were killed. We gave short shrift to more important stories about a resurgent Taliban in Afghanistan and a potential civil war in Iraq. On the home front, the tax reform plan got overshadowed by tweets and press conferences. Meanwhile, nothing of consequence came out the fight between Trump, Wilson and the media.

That’s why the public hates politics. The press and politicians put Gold Star families in the middle of political skirmish with no discernible goal. Wilson may have acted hastily and in anger but still her accusation shifted the conversation away from the fallen and onto her and Trump. Trump lied and besmirched Wilson but he does that almost every week (day?) to somebody. He certainly should be called out for it, but it shouldn’t dominate the news cycle for a week because, at the end of the day, we have no additional useful information.  The press is too eager to show that Trump is the one promoting fake news, not them. They would be wiser to take a just-the-facts-,ma’am approach instead of sensationalizing a political battle that has no relevant policy implications. Build the case that he’s untrustworthy but don’t revel in his fantasy world.  We learned nothing new from this whole episode. It just reconfirmed people’s view that our politics is dysfunctional and petty.


  1. Willard Cottrell

    IMHO, the real loser was any confidence in Kelly. He turns out to be a POS, trumPutin supporter. There is no vestige of truth in this WH at all. I was beginning to believe that Kelly would be a positive influence – even though I find the military full of shit (I am a Vet BTW). From Flynn to Boykin, Betrayus and now Kelly. I believe we are in a world of trouble

  2. Jay Ligon

    The President of the United States lies. He tells big lies, little lies, stupid lies. He lies even when the truth is immediately available to the fact-checking world. He lies about telling lies. His representatives tell lies to cover for him. There should be a scroll at the bottom of the television screen warning viewers that Trump cannot be believed. It is like Groundhog Day. It is as if the press learns every day, for the first time, that the President of the United States does not tell the truth.

    He lies about what people say. He lies about what he says. He lies about public policy. He lies about his sexual assault victims. He lies about his taxes. He lies about his wealth. He lies about his golf scores. He lies about how much work he does. He lies about his intelligence. He lies every day in public, in private, to himself and to others. There is something seriously wrong with him. In due course, we will probably learn that our president has been at the center of an international criminal enterprise, the nexus of several criminal organizations involved in murder, money laundering, terrorism and theft on a grand scale. We may learn that his lies are the least despicable thing about his odious character.

    The presidency is a most difficult job, but there are some things you just do which you can’t really get wrong. You say out loud that Nazis are bad. You call out racists. You console the dead and wounded, their families and friends. You show sympathy for people who have lost loved one. You show compassion for people who have lost their homes, who do not have water, who cannot get medical attention, who have lost everything. You show kindness for those who are less fortunate than yourself. These basic measures of human decency are beyond him. He is a little man. He is a little president. He uses his tiny hands to insult people and spread lies across the Twitter world. Trump’s world begins and ends in the prison of his self-absorbed vanity.

    Trump is a disgrace to a great nation. He is a stain on the flag. He is an embarrassment to decent people, to people who have faith, to Americans who care about our men and women in uniform. He is an insult to the intelligence of people everywhere. He is the single greatest mistake our country has ever made. He is the worst human being to ever step into the Oval Office.

    What he said to the mother of a dead Marine is just more shame on him and more shame on us. His staff lied about what the Congresswoman said. His press secretary lied about his lies. This is the United States in 2017; we put an abysmal failure in charge of our country. It gets worse every day.

  3. Jim Bartow

    Your point against Congresswoman Wilson is that you said: “Wilson went straight to the press”.

    This is not accurate. The White House knew that the president was going to call Myeshia Johnson while she was in the limousine on the way to pick up the body of her husband. The White House had alerted the press so that they would be there when the limousine arrived and they would get some good press from the call inside the limousine.

    That Congresswoman Wilson spoke for the family to this press dispatched by the White House seems to me to me to be not going straight to the press, but rather a unnecessary and misleading “both sides are at fault” argument.

    I Just don’t think that is the case here.

    • Norma Munn

      Thank you for this clarification. I thought that I had a vague memory of what you outlined, but was unsure. I knew it was a conversation heard via speaker phone, which if I knew, General Kelly should have known.

Related Posts


Get the latest posts from PoliticsNC delivered right to your inbox!

You have Successfully Subscribed!