Ideological bankruptcy

by | Mar 28, 2017 | Editor's Blog, HB2 | 4 comments

Republicans rolled into power in North Carolina touting the slogan “North Carolina is open for business.” The small print said “as long as you’re straight, white and Christian.” Since they’ve taken power in the state, the GOP has passed a series of bills that clearly discriminate against the LGBT community and discourage voting among minorities. In response, businesses are boycotting the state and a few are moving out.

Republicans like Lt. Governor Dan Forest claim the economic impact is minimal, only costing the state 0.1% of our GDP. But that’s a reflection of the size of our economy, not the damage done by the loss of businesses. A study by the AP says that HB2 and its negative publicity will cost the state $3.76 billion over 12 years. That’s a lot of money and likely is an underestimation since we don’t know how many companies decided not to consider North Carolina for expansion or conventions.

Forest and his allies seem to have won the fight within the GOP. While some members of the party wanted to repeal the law, Forest has been unabashed supporter of keeping it intact. Forest told the Texas legislature, which is considering a similar measure, that the economic impact of HB2 has been minimal. His supporters have been on social media explaining that a loss of more than $500 million a year isn’t really that much. It’s strange place to find the party of fiscal responsibility.

So, what makes the GOP so intransigent on an issue that’s so damaging to our economy and reputation? Marriage equality. Social conservatives thought they had enshrined discrimination into the constitution when the Supreme Court ruled their beloved Amendment 1 unconstitutional.

House Bill 2 is their backlash. They’re punishing the LGBT community for demanding to be treated equal and they’re using the law to prevent local governments from protecting a minority that’s suffered heavily from discrimination. The repeal effort is stymied because Democrats won’t accept a solution that prevents local nondiscrimination ordinances and the GOP won’t accept one that will.

The debate over repealing House Bill 2 has exposed the North Carolina GOP’s ideological bankruptcy. The party of limited government is using the heavy hand of state government to prevent local control. The party of fiscal responsibility is arguing that losing $500 million a year in business revenue is no big deal. For the GOP right now, discrimination is the overarching principle.


  1. Gailya Paliga

    Fascinating to watch them propagating the excessive economic damage over HB2. Did you catch that Greensboro alone claimed a loss of 14.5 MILLION dollars IN A WEEKEND because the NCAA championships were played in SC over HB2. We were warned. But 14.5 million dollars in one weekend from Republican intractability. Unbelievable damage. The coverage of the estimated 14.5 million dollar loss is even brought to you by Fox News.

    Looking back at that slogan makes me shake my head. After all of the damage they’ve done. The loss of the championships also are upsetting many non-political people around the state.

  2. Brendan

    Q: If you had 100 apples, and Lt. Gov. Dan Forest took 10 of them, how many apples would you have?

    A: There’s no evidence that you have any less apples! Look at all the apples you have! The effects are minimal! You’re doing just fine!

    • mary

      My math brain is screaming at you but my social brain is rolling on the floor laughing. 😀 And I thank you from the bottom of my heart. 🙂

      • Gailya Paliga

        I love both of your comments – Mary and Brendan.

Related Posts


Get the latest posts from PoliticsNC delivered right to your inbox!

You have Successfully Subscribed!